South Korea 4, Scotland 1
Lee Chung Soo (15), Ahn Jung Hwan (56, 87), Yoon Jong Hwan (66)
Dobie (74)
16 May 2002
Busan, South Korea
Att: 52,000


Scotland troop off after the dismal defeat in Busan

Hwang Sun-hong avoids the lunge of Scotland's Gary Caldwell as South Korea's slick passing style impresses

Choi Jin-cheul runs at Scotland's Scott Dobie

Park Ji-Sung skillfully twists away from Gary Caldwell

Scots outclassed by Korea

JONATHAN COATES at the Asiad Stadium

YESTERDAY we witnessed what can happen when international football throws together one team at the zenith of its powers, and another at its historical low ebb. South Korea have never been better; Scotland have never been worse, and this was the ear-splitting result.

Roared on by the cacophony of 52,000 Koreans in a magnificent futuristic stadium, Guus Hiddink’s players were relentless in their crazed pursuit of Scottish scalps and World Cup places. All the stereotypes depicting Far Eastern people as frantic, excitable, tireless workhorses could be applied to this highly-accomplished team.

Their pace was extraordinary, their fitness was Herculean and their goals were stunning. For Scotland, read all of the above, but with tongue lodged in cheek. Berti Vogts was to find the green mountains of Busan no more hospitable to his new Scotland team than the dusty suburbs of Paris, where the new manager’s first experiment resulted in a 5-0 defeat.

South Korea did just as good a job as France of convincing their supporters they will enter this summer’s World Cup on the crest of a wave. The Koreans, adhered to one another by five months of preparation for the pressurised demands of contesting such an event on home soil, have competed in 11 games this year. Scotland have played three. How it showed.

No member of the Scotland party wanted afterwards to use jet-lag as an excuse, but when you play a high-class team in an intimidating arena on the back of a 15-hour flight, two nights’ inadequate slumber and a rearranged training session in torrential rain, you can hardly be expected to perform at optimum fitness.

Beaten for pace almost invariably, tortured by the caverns of space they were unable to cover and outdone for skill more regularly than in any match you could recall, Scotland were mercilessly torn apart, their opponents netting four times and missing two desirable chances to expand this tally.

Vogts, fielding Gary Caldwell and Michael Stewart in the key positions he would normally want occupied by Paul Lambert and Don Hutchison, realised soon enough that his abuse of players’ natural positions would not go unpunished.

With Caldwell losing his position more often than not and David Weir and Christian Dailly failing to establish which centre-half would take the initiative, Korea found right from the start that you could cut through the heart of this team like a knife through butter.

Scot Gemmill lost possession in his own half and, almost before he could turn his head to assess the damage, the Koreans had completed a two-pass move to send clear Lee Shun Soo, the 20-year-old blond striker, through on goal.

Lee was offside at this attempt, but would not have to wait long for further service. It seemed a slightly uncultured long ball from Yoo Sang Chul that set him up for the opening goal, but Weir found himself exposed to the striker’s predatory instincts as the ball drifted over his head.

Lee sprinted forth and fooled his opponent by dummying inside his retrieving tackle. In almost pedestrian fashion he then stepped to the left of Neil Sullivan and slid the ball home with his left foot, just as Graham Alexander came in to challenge.

The reaction of the crowd would have been startling if the din had not been set in motion half-an-hour before the match began. South Korea possess an extraordinarily large official supporters’ club named the Red Devils, who filled the lower half of one quarter of this tremendous bowl-shaped arena and, all bedecked in red, banged drums, sang songs and danced in a degree of unison quite unique among football fans.

The fact their team was winning, of course, only exacerbated the decibel level as Hiddink’s 3-4-3 formation went in search of inflicting further wounds. The Dutchman said at half time that his side should have killed off Scotland in the first half. Had Alexander’s clearance via his groin and face of a teasing cross by Hwang Sun Hong drifted a foot to the left, the mortal strike would have been self-inflicted.

Scotland’s free-kick delivery was tepid and overcooked, and whenever the errant midfield passers found Scott Dobie or Garry O’Connor, they failed to get forward in time to assist.

The hosts attained double figures in their attempts on goal in the first half, and this standard was easily matched in the second. Ahn Jung Hwan, the forward whose presence in the national team has suffered because of his inability to make an impression at Perugia, did not betray any lack of confidence when he turned inside Alexander 22 yards out and directed a firm shot past the onrushing Weir and to the left of Sullivan, who seemed to throw the wrong hand at the ball as it flew past him.

Buoyed by the unstinting hysteria coming from the stands, another substitute made an equally glorious impact. Yoon Jong Hwan’s first contribution was to fire a divine shot high to the right of Sullivan.

After Dobie climbed unmarked to head home Gemmill’s free-kick from the left to convert Scotland’s only real opening, Ahn supplied a fitting coup de grace by making his way into the box and chipping Sullivan quite impeccably with the toes of his left foot.

Just when they thought the trauma was over, the Scots were forced to undergo a humiliating line-up in the centre circle to acknowledge the crowd, and you wonder how many more times they will have to endure such demoralising thumpings.

There may be promise for the future, but in plain terms, the new generation being cultivated by Vogts is still some distance from acquiring comparison with even the most shambling elects of the past.


South Korea: Kim Byung Ji, Kim Tae Young, Hong Myung Bo (Yoon Jong Hwan 65), Choi Jin Cheul (Lee Min Sung 46), Lee Eul Yong, Lee Young Pyo, Song Chong Gug, Yoo Sang Chul, Lee Chun Soo (Cha Du Ri 73), Hwang Sun Hong (Ahn Jung Hwan 46), Park Ji Sung (Choi Tae Uk 73).

Scotland: Sullivan, G Alexander (Stockdale 63), Ross, Weir, Dailly, Caldwell, Johnston (Kyle 66), Gemmill, Dobie, Stewart (Severin 46), O’Connor (Williams 46). Subs not used: Gallacher, N Alexander, Cummings, Wilkie, McFadden.

Referee: N Santhan (Singapore).


Vogts sets a new losing record

Jonathan Coates in South Korea

THERE were times yesterday when you peered down at Berti Vogts, sulking with his hands clasped together in the dugout of the Asiad Stadium, and wondered whether he was beginning to regret having taken charge of the sinking ship that is the national football team. The German has now put together the worst opening three results of any post-War Scotland manager. Vogts has outdone John Prentice who in his ill-fated seven-month spell in charge of the national side also got off to three straight defeats in 1966.

Eleven goals have been conceded under Vogts’ stewardship, and it is becoming clear that the batterings sustained in combat with France and South Korea are unlikely to stand solitary in this chapter of the Hampden annals. Gratifyingly, though, this accomplished former manager of Germany was quick to apprehend thoughts that he is losing faith in the plausibility of his salvage mission. "I’m happy we are playing these games," admitted Vogts after a 4-1 defeat in Busan that might have been more convincing. "It is a very hard job, but a good job. I love it."
 

Nobody was suggesting he should consider throwing in the towel after three friendly internationals, but the abject failure of almost all the players who shone against Nigeria at Pittodrie to recreate that form in a pressurised arena would have shattered a lot of the optimism. Not that the newcomers were the only players worthy of criticism. As stinging as anyone in his verdict of the display, Vogts could only name two players - the debutants, Maurice Ross and goalscorer Scott Dobie - whom he deemed to have gained pass marks.

"The whole team did not work hard enough. They were watching opponents with their eyes, but not their feet. They must get closer to them," he said. "A lot of players looked tired and I don’t know why. I saw a lot of bad things tonight, and some small things that were good. Scott Dobie and Maurice Ross, particularly in the first half, did well. Dobie moves well and looks a good striker. You could see the difference between Dobie and [Garry] O’Connor. But O’Connor is a young guy, and he can learn what to do when he does not have the ball. We stay here for two games, and I think you will see a different team against Denmark on 21 August," he continued. "That is my warm-up date for qualifying, and we must prepare the players better. We had a lot of problems. We had a lot of players not here - experienced guys, and I am waiting for them. We missed [Dominic] Matteo, [Barry] Ferguson and [Paul] Lambert in particular. But what can we do? We have to learn. We have quality, but it was the end of the season, and Korea are a team that have been prepared in the right condition for a World Cup. That is the difference."

Indeed, the easiest conclusion to come to last night was that South Korea have fully justified their inclusion in the planet’s greatest football tournament, despite not having had to qualify.Those of us who lamented Scotland’s failure to do so can perhaps now express relief, because the present limitations of this crop of players mean they would have struggled horribly on that stage.

Neil Sullivan admitted that he was taken aback at the standard of the Koreans’ play. Yet the Tottenham Hotspur goalkeeper agreed with Vogts’ logic that the pain of losing to good opposition must be endured in the long-term interest of the team. "What’s the other way to go about it - play teams that you’re going to beat? You might win some games, but are you going to learn about your players, and see what is out there? You have to play against quality teams."

However, this was a sole voice of positive reflection to come from the troop of dejected, long-faced young men who mooched their way out of the stadium and on a bus back to their palatial seaside hotel. Hong Kong, where the squad will enjoy two free days after arriving today, cannot come quickly enough. But it’s a different matter whether by Monday night, after playing South Africa, they will want nothing more than to flee that part of the world, too. The players are quickly finding that the lessons they are taught in football can be no more enjoyable than those they sat through at school.